.png)
When teams today are looking into a modern ERP, they explore three options: Campfire, Rillet, and Numeric. This article will dive into the Rillet vs. Campfire comparison and cover the up-market alternative, Numeric.
For early and growth-stage startups, ERP predicaments are surprisingly common. For many businesses, they want an ERP that will support the needs of their organization as it scales. Plus, they might already be outgrowing entry-level tools like Quickbooks. However, if they're not ready to commit to an enterprise solution like NetSuite due to its costs and implementation complexity, where do they turn?
A new breed of ERPs has emerged to fill exactly this gap in the market, and they're using embedded AI and automation to help growing companies manage their accounting needs without implementing a full enterprise ERP like NetSuite or Sage Intacct.
The two leading ERP providers in this segment are Rillet and Campfire. The companies have a lot in common:
Early-stage tech companies facing the dilemma described above may find that both Campfire and Rillet meet their needs. But how do they differ, and which one is the right choice?
This article will serve as your guide to understanding Rillet versus Campfire. It will cover the platforms, features, and pros/cons of both vendors from the perspective of early-stage and growth-stage companies. We'll also explore where Numeric fits in, from close management and order-to-cash to a full ERP replacement for teams considering alternatives to their current ERP.
Rillet is an AI-native ERP that automates core financial operations for hypergrowth startups. From general ledger and bank reconciliation to invoicing, and multi-entity consolidation, Rillet enables accounting teams to stay lean while scaling rapidly. They are backed by Sequoia, Andreessen Horowitz and ICONIQ with offices in San Francisco and New York.
Rillet integrates directly with other enterprise tools like Salesforce and Ramp and pairs that with an easy-to-use UI.
Rillet's platform is built around an intelligent general ledger (GL) which serves as the system of record for finance and accounting teams. Rillet is positioned as being "AI-native", meaning it was designed to leverage AI from the ground up and within the GL.
Below are a few features that potentially differentiate Rillet from Campfire and other ERPs:
Here are a few areas where Rillet excels:
Here are a few risks associated with using Rillet:
Rillet doesn't charge by seat or based on revenue. Instead, the company uses custom pricing based on the customer's size, transaction volume, contract complexity, and number of entities. While some sources suggest a three-tiered model, Rillet doesn't make pricing information public; prospective customers must request a custom quote.
For the full breakdown of what drives that quote, see our guide to Rillet pricing.
Campfire was founded in 2023. It was built to be a modern accounting platform with AI-powered features for startups.
Campfire leverages AI to facilitate accounting tasks and democratize access to financial data. Its conversational interface (known as Ember AI) is natively embedded, and enables team members to obtain data or complete tasks using simple natural language queries.
Campfire was part of Y Combinator's 2023 class and works primarily with startups. By providing a "modern general ledger" and centralizing accounting and financial reporting tasks into one platform, Campfire seeks to save customers time and effort at month-end close.
Campfire's platform centers on a GL that serves as the unified system of record. The platform is "AI-first," with its Ember AI agent embedded natively throughout the system, allowing teams to automate tasks like reconciliations, some journal entries, flux analysis, and basic financial reporting with simple natural language queries.
Here are a few areas where Campfire excels:
Here are a few risks associated with using Campfire:
Campfire doesn't share any pricing information publicly, and prospective customers must request a custom quote. However, third parties have noted that Campfire offers "lower upfront costs" compared to NetSuite.
Rillet and Campfire both provide AI-native ERP solutions, but choosing between the two depends on your organization's specific needs. The feature-by-feature comparison table below may clarify which solution is best-suited to your use case.
Rillet delivers basic native ASC 606 and IFRS 15 automation. The platform supports allocation, scheduling, and tracking across revenue structures.
Campfire automates some workflows like journal preparation and unbilled receivables, providing effective coverage for smaller organizations. For companies with materially complex revenue accounting demands, Numeric's billing + revenue module is likely to offer greater specialization and depth.
Rillet focuses on intelligent GL automation that reduces manual accounting effort. This approach emphasizes process control and operational efficiency by standardizing ledger activity while keeping a human in the loop at all times.
Campfire combines automated ledger functionality with conversational interaction, allowing users to query and navigate financial data with natural language. Rillet concentrates on reducing accounting workload, while Campfire emphasizes data accessibility and interaction. Both platforms aim to reduce the time required for the month-end close.
Rillet's Aura AI supports accounting teams by autonomously booking relevant journal entries, generating real-time insights, and automating mundane tasks. Rillet's AI is trusted by accountants; AI-generated answers always have explanations and source documentation. Generally, Rillet focuses on augmenting professional workflows and improving execution efficiency.
Campfire's Ember AI enables conversational access to financial information, improving utility for team members outside of finance thanks to natural-language queries. Ember differentiates Campfire in cross-functional accessibility, while Rillet is more closely tied to finance team operations.
Both platforms integrate with modern finance-stack tools like Salesforce, Stripe, and Rippling.
Numeric takes a different approach with the Numeric MCP. In addition to traditional integrations, it gives your own AI interface a single connection point to every tool in your stack, so your team can orchestrate accounting work directly from wherever they're already working, instead of stitching partner integrations together.
In the clearest way, AI-native ERPs differ by bringing AI to the table. Between Campfire's Ember AI and Rillet's AI, accounting teams can use conversational interfaces to build simple automation and handle tasks.
However, in some ways, these tools are just another generation of existing ERP architecture. They still function with a traditional general ledger model, built on submitting journal entries, creating a chart of accounts, and needing to maintain separate subledgers.
Compared to legacy ERPs like NetSuite and Sage, Rillet and Campfire offer a handful of interface upgrades and some automation, but they build those upgrades on top of the same general ledger model as NetSuite.
Real-time data, embedded AI, and a modern interface are all upgrades layered on top of the same underlying model. In Rillet and Campfire, every transaction still gets recorded as a journal entry.
This approach tends to stop being worth it once a company scales into more complex revenue models, higher transaction volumes, and a finance team ready to work closer to the data itself.
Numeric's Financial Data Platform closes that gap as an ERP replacement, with a new architecture underneath, not just a new interface on top. This allows capabilities like:
The difference shows up in what the system is built to do with information. An interface layered onto an existing accounting model, like Rillet or Campfire, is still limited by what that model can capture, no matter how modern it looks.
Watch how Numeric is rearchitecting the data platform finance runs on.
Choosing between Rillet and Campfire depends on your company's specific needs, current systems, and growth trajectory. Depending on those needs, it might be worthwhile to consider ERP alternatives like Numeric.
Here are criteria to consider for each of the following:
Choose Rillet if:
Choose Campfire if:
Consider Numeric if:
Rillet and Campfire are a step up from a legacy ERP, but they're still built on the same foundation. Numeric's Financial Data Platform runs on data-centric accounting instead, a different way of running finance built for the complexity that comes with scale and the AI era .
Numeric is the right fit for teams whose revenue models, transaction volumes, or entity structures have grown more complex than an AI-native ERP is built to support, and who want their AI tools working from real, structured data instead of a summarized line.
If your team is ready for that shift, the Financial Data Platform is where to start. Schedule a demo with Numeric to learn more.